clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

City Council Members Bringing Back Participatory Budgeting for Some, Not All

City Councilmember Carlos Menchaca speaks with voters in his Brooklyn district about participatory budgeting, May 9, 2018.
City Councilmember Carlos Menchaca speaks with voters in his Brooklyn district about participatory budgeting, May 9, 2018.
John McCarten/New York City Council

At the onset of the pandemic last year, the city suspended participatory budgeting — the grassroots democratic process that allows the public to propose community projects, develop them with experts and then vote on which ones to fund.

On Monday, four City Council members — three of whom are running for higher office — announced they’re bringing back the program for their districts in time for its 10th anniversary. This time, the proceedings will all be online due to the COVID-19 crisis.

Council members Carlos Menchaca (D-Brooklyn), Brad Lander (D-Brooklyn), Ben Kallos (D-Manhattan) and Stephen Levin (D-Brooklyn) said they’re putting aside a combined total of more than $4.5 million to fund projects within their local neighborhoods.

“Participatory budgeting is the spirit of an inclusive recovery at this moment, especially when we need people to come together and restore our city,” said Lander, who helped introduce participatory budgeting to New York, via the City Council, in 2011.

Councilmember Brad Lander (D-Brooklyn) gathers signatures in Downtown Brooklyn to get on the ballot in the comptroller’s race, March 2, 2021.
Councilmember Brad Lander (D-Brooklyn) gathers signatures in Downtown Brooklyn to get on the ballot in the comptroller’s race, March 2, 2021.
Ben Fractenberg/THE CITY

Meanwhile, the fledgling citywide participatory budgeting program, established by voters through referendums in late 2018, hasn’t been fully rolled out due to Mayor Bill de Blasio’s pandemic-spurred emergency executive order last April.

Lander, a candidate for city comptroller, earmarked more than $1.5 million to fund projects in his district, which includes Carroll Gardens, Park Slope and Windsor Terrace. Menchaca, who is running for mayor, put aside $2 million in capital funding for his district, which encompasses Red Hook and Sunset Park.

“The most important thing about democracy is participation,” Menchaca told THE CITY. “And participatory budgeting has given us the ability as Council members, representatives of the districts, to bring that power back to people so that they can decide how to invest capital money into their communities.”

Kallos, a candidate for Manhattan borough president whose district includes the Upper East Side, designated $1 million. Levin put aside $30,000 for his district, covering north Brooklyn waterfront neighborhoods, including Greenpoint and Williamsburg.

Residents of those districts will be able to vote for project proposals from April 5 to April 14 on websites created by their Council member’s office.

‘Racial and Economic Inequality’

Past projects that got funded have included improvements to playgrounds, increased neighborhood video surveillance and an all-gender bathroom installed at a school.

In 2019, more than 118,000 New Yorkers voted on projects, allocating more than $39 million for 145 of them, according to Juan Soto, a City Council spokesperson.

But the program got suspended last March due to safety precautions, as well as concerns that voting entirely online would have disenfranchised too many people, said Soto, whose boss, City Council Speaker Corey Johnson, is also running for comptroller.

Lander said it’s possible to restore participatory budgeting “in ways that are mindful of the racial and economic inequality we saw so painfully during the pandemic.”

City Council Speaker Corey Johnson (D-Manhattan) speaks at a press conference in Foley Square about passing legislation for more police accountability, June 2, 2020.
City Council Speaker Corey Johnson (D-Manhattan) speaks at a news conference in Foley Square about passing legislation for more police accountability, June 2, 2020.
Ben Fractenberg/THE CITY

The Civic Engagement Commission, established by the 2018 referendum, wasn’t able to expand participatory budgeting citywide due to the mayor’s emergency order.

The order halted certain government operations, “including suspending the deadline for citywide participatory budgeting for the duration of the COVID-19 emergency declaration,” said Daniel Abramson, a spokesperson for the Civic Engagement Commission. “This executive order remains in effect.”

But the Commission did launch a modified pilot program for young people that started in October.

“New Yorkers age 9 through 24 voted on how to allocate $100k on a range of proposals addressing topics like arts & culture, mental health, education, and job training,” Abramson wrote in a statement. “Not only did youth decide how to allocate the funding but they were critical to shaping and running the process itself.”

In early March, the Commission announced five winners of the online “It’s Our Money” program, including a garden project, mentorship program and music training.

A Welcome Comeback

Caron Atlas, director of Arts & Democracy, an organization that helps New Yorkers create visual representations of their proposals, said she was at a workshop last year when she heard the city suspended participatory budgeting.

“We’d gotten about halfway through it last year, and everything was put on pause,” Atlas said.

Atlas applauded the Council members who decided to bring it back, as well as the community members who demanded that the participatory budgeting be restored.

“My feeling is during the pandemic — and this is speaking as a community member — you feel like everything’s out of your control, right?” she said. “Everything is happening to you and you have very little agency within it, and within PB you do have agency. That’s why I’m so enthusiastic about it.”

SUPPORT LOCAL NEWS. SUPPORT NEW YORK.

THE CITY is an independent, nonprofit newsroom dedicated to hard-hitting reporting that serves the people of New York. Please consider joining us as a member today.

GOT A TIP?

We’re here to listen. Email tips@thecity.nyc or visit our tips page for other ways to share.

Sign up for the newsletter Get THE CITY Scoop

Sign up and get the latest stories from THE CITY delivered to you each morning